American-British banker Sir John Templeton once warned that the four most dangerous words in investing are: “This time it’s different.” They appear deceptively comforting, whether markets are soaring or sinking, but more often than not they signal trouble ahead.
During bull markets, investors crave narratives that suggest fundamentals no longer matter. Think back to the late-1990s dot-com boom: the internet did reshape the world, yet not every start-up deserved a sky-high valuation. Pets.com and Webvan proved that reality eventually reasserts itself. The housing bubble of the mid-2000s told a similar story. Financial engineering created AAA-rated mortgage investments, and many believed US home prices could never fall nationwide. We all know how that ended.
Today, echoes of “this time it’s different” can be heard in cryptocurrencies, meme stocks, and artificial intelligence. These technologies may transform industries, but investors should remember that first movers don’t always stand the test of time. Just ask fans of Palm Pilots or BlackBerrys. Trade tariffs present another cautionary tale: while they can shift supply chains and boost domestic industries, they also raise costs and squeeze margins. Narratives alone cannot repeal economic laws.
The danger isn’t confined to euphoric rallies. In bear markets, investors often insist that “this time it’s different – this isn’t a cycle, it’s the end!” We heard it during the 2008 financial crisis and again early in the pandemic. Yet history shows that volatility is normal. From 1980 to 2024, the S&P 500 experienced an average intra-year decline of roughly 14%, but still finished positive in 31 of the last 40 years. Markets have survived wars, recessions, tariffs, and pandemics. Recovery is part of the cycle.
The antidote is discipline. Focus on fundamentals—earnings, cash flow, balance sheets—and always consider both upside and downside scenarios. Ask: What if the prevailing narrative is wrong? Technology and policy may evolve, but valuation, risk, and human psychology remain constant.
Before chasing the next big story or panic-selling at the bottom, consider Templeton’s warning and that markets change, but the rules of prudent investing do not.
Your Wealth Management Team
CONTACT THE WEALTH MANAGEMENT TEAM
"*" indicates required fields
